Lefty's on the Square

4.7 (110 reviews )
$$
Restaurant
Dine-in
Delivery
Dinner
Catering
+(10)

About Lefty's on the Square

Lefty's on the Square, located in the heart of Magnolia, Arkansas, is a gem that promises both exceptional cuisine and an inviting atmosphere. With a focus on community and customer experience, the restaurant’s dedicated staff, including the engaging owner Christy and talented Chef Bailey, ensures every visit feels special. Diners rave about the delicious dishes—from crave-worthy potstickers to inventive cocktails—crafted with passion and precision. The unique bar and charming decor create the perfect backdrop for memorable evenings, whether celebrating a milestone or enjoying a casual dinner. Lefty’s embodies the spirit of culinary excellence, making it a must-visit destination.

Reviews (110) 4.7

  • Travis Roe
    Jul 22,2025

    We drove five and a half from Rogers for our anniversary just to check this place out! Their marketing on social media drew our curiosity and they exceeded all of our expectations! We stopped in just for drinks the first night. Lorenzo, (the marketing manager) and Christy (the owner) came and sat with us and we immensely enjoyed getting to know them and their story. The staff was amazing and they visited with us for much of the night, as well. They really made us feel like VIP’s. Their pride in what they do really shows! We enjoyed it so much we were the last ones to leave and closed the place down with them. We came back the next night for dinner and have never felt more special! The food and cocktails were excellent! Lorenzo reserved their best booth for us for the entire night. They made a personalized card for us wishing us a Happy Anniversary and signed and wrote us little notes on the back. We are soooo glad we made the trip down! It was an incredible weekend we’ll never forget!

  • Jesse Dorris
    Jul 22,2025

    Had a great experience. I had been on carnivore for a week up until this day, they were going to accommodate my diet, but I gave into the delicious food.

  • Terry Clark
    Jul 22,2025

    Wow. Not what I expected in Magnolia Arkansas. Food, great. Service, great. Atmosphere, you gotta see it to enjoy it. Madi was our server and you couldn’t ask for better. Knowable she was. Helpful, of course. Would definitely recommend for a quiet dinner for two or just an afternoon drink. Oh you gotta see the bar. It’s designed like no other and the seats are even comfortable. In town, give it a try.

  • Tamra Corley
    Jul 22,2025

    Drop what you’re doing and make your way to Magnolia for not just a great meal but a fabulous dining experience! The Lefty’s team really has something special here and you can for sure see the love they have put into every detail! Our server, Seth, was just precious and you knew he genuinely was happy to be at work. The food was delicious and the drinks fun! We will definitely be back and be back often!

  • Kristy Hansen
    Jul 22,2025

    This was one of the absolute BEST experiences we could have asked for! Our server Kessa was so kind and attentive! The owner Christy came over and talked with my Mom and I multiple times during dinner; and even allowed me to view the upstairs special event dining room area after that evening’s guests departed. On our way back down from viewing the upstairs, I had the joy of meeting the chef, Bailey… a super cute young woman chef!! I expressed to her how impressed I was with her skills; and how amazing the food was. The potstickers were SO amazing, I literally dreamed about them; and decided to return the following evening for cocktails at the bar and more potstickers! The 2nd evening I met even more of the amazing staff, Lexi & McKenna (bartenders); and I will say my 2nd visit was just as amazing as my first! I cannot recommend this place more!! I am from Colleyville (a suburb of the Dallas-Fort Worth area in Texas). I wish we had an establishment exactly like this one in our area!!! It would be packed constantly! So sad I cannot scoop up the venue, staff, owner, food … all the things; and bring them home with me to Texas! I suggest you come for a wonderful experience; you will not be regretful you did!

  • bill Mow
    Jul 22,2025

    This is top of the line for dining here Service was good and Atmosphere super. But both our side dishes were cool and the potatoes lumpy Not a good combination. We checked with other folks who have dined here who had the same issues I believe we had the same issue on another evening and were told they need to turn the steam table up Put a smudge on an otherwise nice meal Our second visit was even better than the first. Courtney our server was delightful and very professional. We were pleased that the owner noticed our first comments and had really stepped up the candied bacon presentation. She brought us a sample and we spent a nice few moment visiting. The spicy beef cheese appetizer was wonderful a must try again. A delightful well served and plated meal in great surroundings was a most welcome evening. An excellent up scale dinning experience now available in Magnolia This new restaurant is working hard to put forth a great product. The ambiance is great with many interesting things to see. Out selections were well plated and very tasty. One very small disappointment was our candied bacon while quite tasty lacked a bit in presentation An upscale bread selection could be a nice addition Definitely great choice for many return visits

  • Josh Klober
    Jul 22,2025

    **Five Stars for Lefty’s – Magnolia’s Best Spot!** Tucked away in Southern Arkansas, Lefty’s in Magnolia is a downright classy place to eat and have a good time. The restaurant is perfect for couples looking for a special night out or for grabbing a meal and some drinks with friends and family when they’re in town. The vibe is just right—nice enough to feel special but still cozy and welcoming. The food is top-notch, with something for everybody, and Josh is the best bartender around. Whether you’re there to celebrate or just hang out, Lefty’s always delivers. This place is a true Magnolia treasure, making our town even better. Five stars ain’t enough—I’d give Lefty’s ten if I could! Thanks for calling Magnolia, AR home and giving us a spot to make memories. Josh K.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Lefty's on the Square?

    Lefty's is known for its delicious potstickers and creative cocktails, along with a variety of small plates that cater to different tastes.

  • Do I need to make a reservation to dine at Lefty's?

    While reservations are recommended, especially for dinner, walk-ins are also welcome and typically accommodated.

  • What are the dining options available at Lefty's?

    You can enjoy dine-in service or opt for takeaway if you'd prefer to enjoy your meal elsewhere.

  • What is the atmosphere like at Lefty's?

    Lefty's offers a cozy and upscale vibe, perfect for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends and family.

  • Is parking available at Lefty's?

    Yes, there is free parking available, including a lot and street parking options that are wheelchair accessible.

Nearby Restaurants

Restaurant
AllyAnne's Kolache Kitchen

9533 FM 1488 #1700, Magnolia, TX 77354, United States

Restaurant
El Parian

1521 US-82 BUS, Magnolia, AR 71753, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page